In a previous life I was a sportscaster, having worked primarily in Las Vegas. I still dabble in sports a few times a year as a freelancer at KGO in San Francisco.
Next to my faith and family, my true love is college football. And mine is a lone voice among the throng of media who clamor for a playoff to determine college football’s national champion.
What’s wrong with a little controversy… a little debate… even, yes, a little (or a lot) of uncertainty. A playoff would damage the regular season. Imagine if there was an 8-team format. Oklahoma, for example, may have sat Sam Bradford in its regular season finale against Texas Tech in fear of injury.
And the excitement of the regular season would be spoiled. USC’s game with Oregon State took on a playoff feeling, because a Trojan loss would potentially kill its National Title hopes (which it did).
It’s nice to hear others who feel the same. Mark Beech of SI.com writes, “If it were up to me, we'd go back to the old bowl system tomorrow -- you know, the one that worked just fine for most of the 20th century. My reason for this, primarily, is the preservation of the regular season. A playoff couldn't help but render some regular season games meaningless to championship contenders. And at that point, college football, in my opinion, would basically become college basketball, a game which redeems its modestly interesting regular season with a sublime postseason.”
I’m curious. Are there any other oldtimers like myself who like the old system with conference tie-ins to bowl games. You know, Pac10-/Big-10 champs in the Rose Bowl; SEC champ in the Sugar Bowl; and Big 12 champ in the Orange Bowl?
If there has to be a playoff… how about this: Go back to the old conference tie-ins followed by a 3-team playoff. Rank the teams after the bowls. No. 1 gets a bye, No.’s 2 and 3 play for the right to play for No. 1.
This way traditionalists are happy; the bowls have meaning and the polls matter, as the No.-1 ranked team gets a bye… and if they get rid of the conference championship games, the season is extended for only one extra week.
What are your thoughts? I’d like to know.